The Dutch Future Pensions Act (Wtp) involves more than just a new pension contract. It also affects pension funds’ investment policies. This makes it the right time to reassess the foundations of investment policy: investment beliefs.
These beliefs, the principles that guide strategic choices, should be reassessed now that age-dependent investing is becoming the norm, greater transparency is required, and participants’ risk appetite explicitly forms part of investment policy. Existing beliefs will remain relevant, but adjustments are inevitable. The new system requires different areas of emphasis, sharper wording, and potentially even additional beliefs aimed at making sound decisions within the revised investment policy.
Investment beliefs as a foundation
Investment beliefs form the foundation of every investment policy. These core principles express a pension fund’s views on topics such as risk, return, sustainability, and implementation. They provide coherence across strategic choices and ensure that policy aligns with the fund’s participant profile and objectives.
DNB emphasizes the importance of investment beliefs within the investment cycle. Sound policy starts with defining the fund’s objectives and policy principles, including its investment beliefs. These provide the framework against which subsequent steps in the investment cycle are assessed, from strategic asset allocation to monitoring. Without clear beliefs, direction and consistency are lacking. Particularly now, with the transition to a new pension system, reassessment is essential.
A closer look at current investment beliefs
An analysis of the ten largest Dutch pension funds shows that their investment beliefs can generally be divided into six categories:
- Investment theory | Diversification and a long-term perspective form the foundation, potentially complemented by a view on active and passive investing.
- Risk premia | Risks should only be taken when they are expected to be rewarded, such as equity, credit, and illiquidity premia. Unrewarded risks, such as interest rate and currency risk, are hedged.
- Responsible investment | Responsible investment criteria and ESG risks are integrated into the investment process as standard practice, sometimes complemented by sustainability-related objectives or an allocation to impact investments.
- Cost awareness | Costs are important but are weighed against expected returns and the interests of participants.
- Investment process | Strategic asset allocation determines the risk-return profile. Risk management, transparency, and consistent decision-making contribute to well-informed investment decisions.
- Organization | Policy must be implementable within the constraints of governance, operational capacity, and complexity.
These beliefs were largely developed under the FTK framework, in which hedging liabilities, balance sheet management, and a single collective investment portfolio were central. Interestingly, the scope of investment beliefs has broadened in recent years. Topics such as communication, participant engagement, and the design of the pension contract are increasingly included. This broader scope is understandable: pension funds want to be able to explain and justify their policies in an integrated manner. At the same time, this should not undermine the clarity and ability of investment beliefs to provide direction.
Wtp brings a shift in focus
Under the Wtp, the focus shifts from nominal (perceived) certainty towards expected value and optimizing pension outcomes.
The traditional collective investment portfolio is being replaced by a lifecycle approach in which participants are divided into age cohorts, each with its own risk profile. Under the solidarity-based pension scheme, this translates into an age-dependent allocation of returns from the return and protection portfolios. Younger participants can take more investment risk as a result of the removal of the borrowing constraint. Under the flexible pension scheme, this differentiation goes a step further: participants choose an investment profile that reflects their risk appetite.
The approach to interest rate risk is also changing. Whereas previously a single fixed hedge ratio at fund level was sufficient, the new system requires an explicit assessment for each cohort of whether, and to what extent, protection against changes in interest rates is necessary.
What remains, what shifts, and what changes?
The transition to the new pension system does not mean that existing investment beliefs should be abandoned entirely. Many principles remain relevant, while others require revised wording or a fundamentally different interpretation. At the same time, new considerations may emerge that require explicit beliefs. The impact can be divided into three categories:
- Beliefs that remain
Core principles of investment theory, such as the importance of strategic asset allocation, diversification, the trade-off between active and passive investing, and only taking rewarded risks, remain relevant. Sustainability and cost awareness also remain essential principles. - Beliefs that shift
A single long investment horizon for the pension fund as a whole gives way to a lifecycle approach that distinguishes between the accumulation, de-risking, and payout phases. This requires a more differentiated view of risk and return. Investment risks and investment horizons, for example, need to be aligned with the risk appetite and preferences of each age cohort.The belief regarding interest rate risk and its hedging also requires reconsideration. The existing belief that interest rate risk is unrewarded and should therefore be hedged by default does not always hold under the Wtp. For younger participants, it may be rational not to hedge interest rate risk, while greater protection may remain desirable for older participants. This requires a more refined belief for each age cohort. - Emerging beliefs
New policy choices may require new investment beliefs. These could include clear principles on the use of the solidarity reserve or whether to remove the borrowing constraint for younger participants. A clear belief regarding the added value of removing the borrowing constraint – for example, by allowing younger participants to have more than 100% exposure to the return portfolio based on their risk appetite – can provide direction for investment policy.
Without beliefs, there is no direction
The Wtp requires pension funds to reassess the foundations of their investment policies. Investment beliefs, the principles that guide strategic choices, need to be revisited. Not because they have lost their value, but because the environment in which they operate is changing.
Age-dependent investing, individual risk profiles, and changing considerations around interest rate hedging require beliefs to be reformulated, refined, or even fundamentally redesigned. At the same time, new considerations may emerge that require explicit beliefs, such as the use of the solidarity reserve or the removal of the borrowing constraint.
Beliefs concerning lifecycle investing and interest rate risk in particular go to the heart of the new investment policy. A single collective balance sheet is no longer the central focus; instead, investment policy is differentiated by age and risk appetite. Similarly, interest rate hedging is no longer a uniform policy decision, but a targeted assessment for each cohort. These shifts require a sharper and more up-to-date approach.
Investment beliefs are not merely a requirement on paper, but a strategic instrument. They provide structure to the investment process, offer guidance when making complex trade-offs, and strengthen the consistency and explainability of policy. Clearly formulated beliefs not only provide direction, but also create a robust framework for well-founded decision-making.
At a time when the new system places greater demands on pension funds, investment beliefs are indispensable. Not as a policy formality, but as the foundation for consistent, explainable, and forward-looking investment policy. Reassessing these beliefs is not an isolated exercise: it marks the starting point for a broader review of investment policy.