Row midpoint Shape Decorative svg added to bottom

Risk management in the chain: Are you truly in control?

Outsourcing activities offers financial market participants numerous benefits: cost reduction, access to specialized expertise, and greater focus on their own core activities. At the same time, outsourcing in the financial sector also involves significant risks.

Operational errors, data breaches, or non-compliance by outsourcing partners can result in business disruptions, financial losses, reputational damage, and legal claims. Mandate breaches, where outsourcing partners act beyond the scope of their authority, create an additional risk. Effective control over outsourcing is therefore essential to manage risks, ensure compliance, and maintain the confidence of both clients and regulators.

Careful monitoring of outsourcing arrangements

The recent report published by the Dutch Authority for the Financial Markets (AFM) in September 2024 and new outsourcing requirements under the Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) underline the importance of a structured approach. Although many financial market participants are familiar with the regulatory requirements for risk assessments, due diligence, and outsourcing agreements, they do not always make full use of the potential of these steps.

Sound risk management starts with a careful selection process and thorough due diligence focused on the risks that are relevant to the financial market participant. These include financial, operational, legal, and regulatory risks, as well as sustainability risks. Such an assessment provides a snapshot of a potential outsourcing partner’s performance and risks. Circumstances can change, however. New regulations, regulatory guidance, and changes to an outsourcing partner’s operational approach can introduce new risks.

An annual compliance statement from the outsourcing partner often provides insufficient insight into how risks are actually managed within processes and how obligations are met. Continuous monitoring is therefore crucial. This means that financial market participants need to actively monitor how outsourcing partners comply with agreed arrangements and safeguard business continuity and regulatory compliance. Monitoring requires not only adequate information from the outsourcing partner, but also active involvement by the financial market participant itself, for example through periodic meetings. This enables risks to be identified and addressed in a timely manner.

Contractual terms: standard is not enough

In practice, we see that many financial market participants do not make sufficient use of their outsourcing agreements. Standard documentation is often used, while detailed arrangements in underlying documents, such as a Service Level Agreement (SLA), are still lacking. As a result, key obligations are not always fully documented, which can create problems when agreements need to be enforced.

A sound agreement sets out these obligations and includes explicit provisions on monitoring, incident management, and compliance, including appropriate monitoring and audit rights. These rights and obligations are essential for maintaining control over the timely identification and management of outsourcing-related risks and for being prepared to respond to questions from regulators.

Laws and regulations also prescribe specific safeguards that must be included in contracts, such as the aforementioned audit rights, reporting obligations, and business continuity arrangements. These regulatory requirements, however, should only be the starting point. It is essential to use them as a foundation for specific and tailored arrangements that reflect the nature of the outsourced services and the associated risks. Without this concrete implementation, a contract remains an empty shell, making critical obligations difficult to enforce and potentially significantly increasing the risks for the outsourcing financial market participant.

The future of outsourcing

The AFM report also emphasizes the importance of assigning specific individuals responsibility for overseeing outsourcing partners. These individuals should monitor compliance with agreed arrangements, identify changes in risks, and maintain an up-to-date overview of outsourcing relationships. Given the challenges we see in the market when it comes to maintaining adequate control over outsourcing chains, this is a positive development. It not only supports regulatory compliance, but also helps keep risks manageable and prevent escalation.

This aligns with broader trends in the financial sector, where increasing emphasis is being placed on transparency, control, and proactive risk management in outsourcing relationships. The same applies under DORA, which requires financial market participants to further strengthen their ICT risk management. This includes identifying and monitoring ICT risks and their management within outsourced processes, as well as incorporating detailed additional obligations into agreements.

Conclusion

Managing risks in outsourcing relationships and investments requires a strategic and integrated approach. Selection processes and due diligence are an important starting point, but because circumstances can change, continuous monitoring is crucial.

By establishing clear contractual arrangements and proactively monitoring risks, financial market participants can not only maintain control over outsourcing risks, but also retain the confidence of regulators and clients. Only with such an approach are you truly in control.

Author:

Dirk-Jan Gerrits

Diederik van Nieuwkerk

More news

Keeping up to date with AF Advisors