Within the field of investment analysis, the Fama-French Three-Factor Model has played a fundamental role in explaining historical equity returns.
Building on the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), Eugene Fama and Kenneth French introduced two additional factors alongside market risk in their statistical model to better explain equity returns: size (SMB – Small Minus Big market capitalization) and value (HML – High Minus Low book-to-market). These factors reflect the long-term premiums of small-cap stocks over large-cap stocks and value stocks over growth stocks.
Both premiums are attributed to a combination of risk-based and behavioral explanations. Risk-based theories argue that small-cap and value stocks carry greater systematic risks, such as financial vulnerability, cyclical sensitivity, or limited access to capital, thereby justifying higher expected returns. At the same time, behavioral theories point to market inefficiencies resulting from certain investor preferences, such as the overvaluation of growth stocks and the neglect of small-cap and value stocks, creating opportunities for above-average returns.
With the rise of ESG investing, it is relevant to examine how these traditional factors are being affected. Sustainable investing introduces new behavioral dynamics and systematic risks. This article examines how investment decisions from a sustainability perspective affect the traditional size and value premiums and may be changing the dynamics of today’s equity markets. Following a recent period of underperformance by both small-cap and value stocks, these dynamics could act as a catalyst for a revival and strengthening of these factor effects.
ESG investing and its implications
In a relatively short period of time, ESG investing has evolved from a niche segment into an important component of institutional investment portfolios. In this article, ESG investing refers to investment strategies that, to some extent, incorporate choices from a sustainability perspective, such as avoiding ESG risks, creating positive impact, or avoiding negative effects.
The growing emphasis on sustainability has resulted in a shift of capital towards companies that meet minimum sustainability standards and are perceived to have relatively low ESG risk. This has led to a preference for large growth stocks in sectors such as technology and renewable energy. At the same time, sectors traditionally associated with value stocks, such as energy, commodities, and utilities, have come under greater scrutiny because of their environmental impact and the risk of stranded assets.
To understand how ESG investing affects the size and value premiums, it is important to link the risk-based and behavioral explanations to current market developments.
Risk-based explanations
Historically, value and small-cap stocks have offered higher returns as compensation for their risks. ESG investing, however, introduces an additional layer of risks that may strengthen or weaken these premiums.
Value stocks: Many value stocks operate in sectors with an elevated risk of stranded assets, such as fossil fuels, traditional industries, and utilities. Stranded assets arise when regulation, changing consumer demand, or technological innovation causes existing assets, such as coal-fired power plants or oil reserves, to lose their economic value. An oil company with large untapped reserves, for example, could face a rapid decline in value during a net-zero transition.
Investors may demand higher returns as compensation for these ESG-related risks, which could strengthen the value premium. However, if these risks materialize more rapidly or severely than expected, for example as a result of unexpectedly stricter carbon taxes or a very rapid transition to renewable energy, this could instead lead to a decline in the value of these companies.
Small-cap stocks: Small-cap companies often have fewer resources available to implement comprehensive ESG policies and comply with reporting standards. This increases their risk profile and makes them more vulnerable to regulatory sanctions or reputational damage. Investors may therefore demand higher returns as compensation, potentially strengthening the size premium.
Behavioral explanations
In addition to risk-related factors, investor biases play a role in explaining the size and value premiums.
Preference for ESG companies: Investor preferences for more sustainable companies may lead to the overvaluation of growth stocks, such as renewable energy or technology companies, because of their alignment with sustainability objectives. This may cause investors to overpay for future earnings growth, similar to the historical overvaluation of growth stocks. At the same time, value stocks in ‘brown’ sectors, such as oil and mining, may be avoided even when they are undervalued relative to their fundamental value, thereby increasing the value premium.
Attention to small-cap stocks: Small-cap stocks generally receive less attention from analysts and institutional investors, and ESG investing may reinforce this effect. Many small-cap companies provide less ESG data, making them less attractive to ESG-focused investors. This may put further downward pressure on their valuations, thereby strengthening the size premium.
Limitations of backtesting
Analyzing the impact of ESG investing on the Fama-French factors is complicated by the limitations of backtesting:
- Recent rise of ESG investing: ESG investing is a relatively recent phenomenon, meaning that historical datasets often contain insufficient ESG data.
- Structural market shifts: The increasing adjustment of investment portfolios based on ESG criteria represents a structural shift in market preferences. Backtests spanning several decades may not fully capture the behavioral and regulatory changes underlying this shift, potentially leading to misleading conclusions.
- Evolving metrics and standards: ESG criteria and reporting standards continue to evolve, resulting in inconsistencies in the data available for backtests.
Forward-looking analysis and scenario planning are therefore becoming increasingly important when assessing the impact of ESG investing on market structures.
A changing landscape for size and value premiums
The interaction between ESG investing and the Fama-French model illustrates how equity markets are changing.
- Risk-based factors: ESG-related risks, such as stranded assets and regulatory uncertainty, may strengthen the size and value premiums or, conversely, erode them if risks materialize and entire sectors lose value prematurely.
- Behavioral factors: The preference for more sustainable companies may create inefficiencies in which growth stocks become overvalued and small-cap and value stocks become undervalued, further strengthening these premiums.
- Limitations of backtesting: Investors need to recognize the limitations of traditional backtesting in an ESG context and prioritize forward-looking analysis to account for this rapidly changing landscape.
The integration of sustainability into investment strategies is changing the dynamics of traditional risk premiums. ESG investing introduces new behavioral and systematic risks that may strengthen the classic Fama-French size and value factors. Investors who understand these shifts will be better positioned to respond to these structural changes in financial markets.