Row midpoint Shape Decorative svg added to bottom

Sustainability in its teenage years

In my family, I experience the joys of raising teenagers every day, ranging from heated discussions and frustration to apathetically lounging on the sofa. I see signs of this adolescence in my work too: fifteen years ago, sustainable investing was still in its infancy; today, we are clearly in the teenage years.

The first similarity I see is about ‘fitting in’. NZAM recently published its new list of companies endorsing the initiative, which showed that several major names were missing, including Invesco and Franklin Templeton, while others, such as Wellington and Columbia Threadneedle, had committed only part of their activities. This was not entirely surprising following BlackRock’s earlier departure and the temporary suspension of the initiative. After the changes to the ‘commitment’ in October, members were given a period in which they could opt out.

For investors, this raises the question: how much does it matter if their asset manager withdraws? What does leaving NZAM actually say about the direction a company is taking? How important is this for the services you procure from that party? And how do you assess whether they still meet your expectations?

In early March, Swedish insurer Länsförsäkringar asked its asset managers to (re)join NZAM or otherwise clearly communicate their ambitions through other channels – for example, through the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) or other public, company-wide targets. If asset managers fail to meet its expectations, their position as fund managers could be at risk. Of course, carrying out these checks is difficult and time-consuming, but it illustrates how important it is to move beyond thinking solely in terms of requirements and instead focus on objectives. In other words, the requirement ‘NZAM member’ is not what ultimately matters; the objective is: ‘the asset manager has a credible policy for contributing to the fight against climate change’.

Because focusing solely on what we do not want will not bring about enough change. That is a challenge at home too: I regularly say, ‘don’t spend all day looking at a screen, don’t slouch on the sofa, don’t eat so unhealthily’, when I would be better off focusing on what I do expect and why.

It’s about what you do, not what you avoid

At the end of February, Urgewald, together with Finanzwende and Facing Finance, conducted research into the potential consequences of the newly proposed SFDR rules. According to the research, investment funds would have to divest €8.9 billion due to exposure to fossil fuels that does not comply with the newly proposed rules. That is a significant amount, but where does it come from? Do these companies currently fit the strategies of these funds? Did they rightly or wrongly pass the screening process because they may have an ambitious and credible transition plan? Or are the funds’ current exclusion criteria simply too non-committal?

Here too, I would like to see the focus shift, with less emphasis on what you do not want to invest in. Instead, focus primarily on whether the selection process results in companies that actually contribute to the objective the fund is pursuing. Because if you want something to change, it is ultimately about what you do, not what you avoid.

Stricter exclusion rules can, of course, contribute to greater transparency and awareness. After all, another familiar teenage trait is testing boundaries. How far can I go? Where is the real limit? We see the same thing in sustainable investing. New rules around SFDR, naming, and exclusions provide greater clarity through definitions and thresholds. At the same time, there is a risk that the discussion shifts towards what is still formally permitted rather than what is desirable in substance. Is the objective really being achieved if a fund stays precisely within the rules, but its underlying investments barely contribute to the intended transition? Maturity means not only complying with the rules, but also respecting their spirit and being willing to look beyond the minimum requirements.

Staying on the sofa

The final similarity concerns the different attitudes of teenagers. One is ambitious and active, with clear goals and determined to achieve them. Another has doubts and prefers to wait passively, especially when things are not going their way. I see the same thing in the market as a result of geopolitical developments and the anti-ESG sentiment spreading from the US. Some are vocal and steadfast in their sustainability ambitions, while others pause or even reconsider choices they have already made. Others continue to move forward quietly, without drawing attention to themselves.

Here too, the question is: what is the intended objective? When it comes to climate change in particular, the urgency to act remains high, both from a risk management perspective and from the perspective of creating a more sustainable future. Perhaps that is the essence of this adolescent phase: searching for an identity, exploring boundaries, and determining your position. Choosing where you want to belong, setting clear rules, and sometimes questioning earlier choices are all part of the process.

Ultimately, however, growing up is about consistency between ambition and behavior. Implementation and actual portfolios need to align with the intended objectives and intentions. Taking that step from teenager to adult requires clarity, perseverance, and a willingness to follow through on choices consistently, even when the world around you is changing. How you approach this differs from one person or organization to another, but passively staying on the sofa without a goal is not an option.

Author:

Petra Stassen

More news

Keeping up to date with AF Advisors