The Wtp transition is entering a critical phase over the next two years. The final deadline for transferring accrued pension entitlements to the new system is effectively less than two years away. This creates a challenging combination of significant time pressure, complex changes to pension administration and asset management, and substantial IT risks.
For pension funds, the key question is how they can maintain sufficient control over this far-reaching change and transition to the new system in a controlled and responsible manner.
Complexity and risks
The combination of a complex system reform and significant IT dependencies places considerable demands on scarce capacity and expertise, both at pension funds and pension administrators. Professionals who can take an integrated view of pension administration, data quality, IT, asset management, and the transition to the new system – and assess the interdependencies between them – are in limited supply.
And because many pension funds have postponed their transition, scarcity and time pressure are increasing further. At the same time, developing a detailed and coherent understanding of the precise impact at the intersection of asset management and pension administration is far from straightforward. This is precisely where many changes occur, including in month-end closing, valuation, and reporting.
The combination of limited integrated insight and increasing time pressure puts sound, careful decision-making and effective risk management across the entire value chain at risk. This is compounded by working within often unfamiliar project and program structures, involving a large number of parties and, at times, conflicting interests. As a result, there is a structurally elevated risk of errors and conflicts of interest.
Value chain partners, particularly pension administrators, carry significant operational responsibility and are under considerable pressure to make sufficient progress. This increases the likelihood of decisions being driven primarily by speed, such as delivering minimum functionality, shortening testing phases, or implementing insufficiently considered fund-specific exceptions. This reduces control over the project, data quality, testing processes, and test results, while increasing the risk of material errors.
Strengthening control
On the pension fund side, pension fund offices often have sufficient pension expertise but lack in-depth knowledge and experience of cross-value-chain administrative process changes, IT changes, and the substantive assessment of IT delivery and progress. Establishing an internal or externally supported quality assurance function can effectively address this gap. This function focuses on improving and safeguarding the quality of processes to prevent errors before they occur.
More specifically, through independent and multidisciplinary review, the quality assurance function ensures that new operational processes, data quality, IT delivery, and sound decision-making within the governance structure are assessed in an integrated manner. The function identifies and escalates material risks in a timely manner, assesses the robustness of system and data choices, monitors data quality and test coverage, and safeguards clear roles and sound decision-making. This enables operational and technical findings to be translated into insights relevant to the board in a timely manner and strengthens the control, transparency, and accountability of the transition program.
Practical implementation
In practice, the quality assurance function consists of a small, senior-level role or a small part-time team. Demonstrable multidisciplinary expertise is key. Expertise in pension administration and data, experience with complex IT and transformation programs, and asset management knowledge are brought together in a single review function. Depending on scale, complexity, and available capacity, this function can be established internally, through a hybrid model, or fully externally. The function is explicitly non-executive, does not form part of program management or the line organization, and works closely with key function holders while respecting their respective responsibilities.
Responsibilities
Quality assurance therefore primarily has a substantive review and challenger role, focused on assessing decisions and progress throughout the transition from an integrated perspective. Its responsibilities include:
- substantive review of value chain changes at the intersection of pension administration, asset management, and IT, including valuation, allocation, reporting, and month-end closing;
- assessment of design choices, data modelling, and fund-specific exceptions in terms of robustness, explainability, and manageability;
- oversight of end-to-end test coverage, including assessment of test results and residual risks;
- identification of material risks and dependencies within and between value chain partners;
- interpretation of technical and operational findings in terms of their impact on board-level decision-making;
- assessment of the feasibility of planning and milestones; and
- assessment of whether control can be demonstrated from a regulatory perspective.
In this way, quality assurance effectively serves as an independent, multidisciplinary expert: an additional pair of eyes on the manageability of the transition throughout the different phases of the program.
This individual or team moves in line with the substantive phases of the program and is involved at points where irreversible decisions are being prepared, such as design phases, testing milestones, and transition and acceptance moments.
Positioning within governance
Quality assurance operates alongside the transition and IT program and has an explicit mandate to assess, escalate, and raise value chain-wide risks at board level, while working closely with key function holders. This positioning creates effective countervailing power, helps prevent conflicts of interest, and strengthens the board’s control over decision-making and progress throughout the entire transformation process.